Invelos Forums->Posts by cassiusdrow |
Page:
1 Previous Next
|
Message |
Details |
The "No" voters said the covers were already correct and that I should create an alternate version.
The disc ID is shared with "A Clockwork Orange: Anniversary Edition" (883929-157761), but the existing scans are also wrong for that release according to the contribution rules.
Since the existing cover scans are from the "Stanley Kubrick: Limited Edition Collection" box set, I would say this disc ID belongs to that box set, and an alternate version should be created for use by the "A Clockwork Orange: Anniversary Edition" release. The contribution notes support this. The disc ID profile was created on Aug 14, 2011, with comment "Cover scan using actual flap from boxset". The disc ID was not added to the Clockwork Orange profile until April 29, 2013.
"Stanley Kubrick: A Life in Pictures / O Lucky Malcolm!" contribution notes http://www.invelos.com/Forums.aspx?task=viewtopic&topicID=551647
"A Clockwork Orange: Anniversary Edition" (883929-157761) http://www.invelos.com/onlinecollections/dvd/PlumPeachy/DVD.aspx?U=883929157761
"A Clockwork Orange: Anniversary Edition" contribution notes http://www.invelos.com/Forums.aspx?task=viewtopic&topicID=516071
Unboxing video for "A Clockwork Orange: Anniversary Edition" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NRDFY5asIW0
Quoting rdodolak:
Quote: Unfortunately, not everyone follows the rules and they try to interpret the rules into what they want them to say.
Then what is the point in having the contribution rules? That's rhetorical. I'm just frustrated because it is so difficult to determine what the rules are sometimes and Invelos no longer provides updates or clarifications. | Posted: Topic Replies: 4, Topic Views: 797 |  | Can anyone explain why my recent submission was declined and three people voted "No"?
I submitted new covers for the "2001: A Space Odyssey", "Lolita", and "Stanley Kubrick: A Life in Pictures / O Lucky Malcolm!" child disc profiles of the "Stanley Kubrick: Limited Edition Collection" box set profile, which is a digibook. The new covers were the covers from the box set profile while the existing covers are scans of the digibook page for the discs. The contribution rules indicate that the child profiles should use the same covers as the box set profile unless the child profiles are individually packaged. The other child discs use the box set covers. The new covers were accepted for "2001: A Space Odyssey" and "Lolita" but they were declined for "Stanley Kubrick: A Life in Pictures / O Lucky Malcolm!".
As far as I can tell, this is an inconsistent application of the contribution rules.
This unboxing video shows how the discs are stored: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d4fgAsPYI5E
Profile links:
Stanley Kubrick: Limited Edition Collection http://www.invelos.com/onlinecollections/dvd/PlumPeachy/DVD.aspx?U=883929165834
2001: A Space Odyssey (link gives me error) http://www.invelos.com/onlinecollections/dvd/PlumPeachy/DVD.aspx?U=I28F2D7CA7AC7388C
Barry Lyndon http://www.invelos.com/onlinecollections/dvd/PlumPeachy/DVD.aspx?U=ID4114E1CAB812094
A Clockwork Orange http://www.invelos.com/onlinecollections/dvd/PlumPeachy/DVD.aspx?U=I0864C9AE01411707
Dr. Strangelove or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb http://www.invelos.com/onlinecollections/dvd/PlumPeachy/DVD.aspx?U=ID6D0BA7EE5F8C5B6
Eyes Wide Shut http://www.invelos.com/onlinecollections/dvd/PlumPeachy/DVD.aspx?U=I5E1694C61C31EBBC
Full Metal Jacket http://www.invelos.com/onlinecollections/dvd/PlumPeachy/DVD.aspx?U=IF9DE04ECBD56A2B9
Lolita http://www.invelos.com/onlinecollections/dvd/PlumPeachy/DVD.aspx?U=I03AACFDC93ED82FF
The Shining http://www.invelos.com/onlinecollections/dvd/PlumPeachy/DVD.aspx?U=I3B2887AABFEFFB17
Spartacus http://www.invelos.com/onlinecollections/dvd/PlumPeachy/DVD.aspx?U=IBC0266566E0644EE
Stanley Kubrick: A Life in Pictures / O Lucky Malcolm! http://www.invelos.com/onlinecollections/dvd/PlumPeachy/DVD.aspx?U=IF47797BE6AADDAD7 | Posted: Topic Replies: 4, Topic Views: 797 |  | Thank you! | Posted: Topic Replies: 4, Topic Views: 4217 |  | Should the production year on disc profiles of TV season sets be the same as the parent UPC profile or should the disc profiles use the earliest air/release date for the episodes on the disc? The contribution rules are not very clear and I have TV seasons in my collection using both methods. | Posted: Topic Replies: 4, Topic Views: 4217 |  |
|
Invelos Forums->Posts by cassiusdrow |
Page:
1 Previous Next
|