Quote:
I am in nearly the same situation.

Yesterday I contributed 10 profiles. Most of them were already contributed with another ean and they are almost entirely equals as there was only a change in the distributor.
So I cloned the profiles, change the ean, made new scans of the covers, corrected some mistakes in overview, removed SRP and release date when I didn't know the new ones.

The first 3 were rejected with "Sources for one or more of the changes and/or additions were non-specific. Please specify the exact source for your changes. (e.g. "Credits from film end credit list", "Previous version UPC#1111111111")"

So I sent it again with commentary "from previous ean : 3-259190-327993" as it was asked to me.
The 3 were accepted but the others 7 were declined for the same reason.
What more is needed ?

Quote:
There was no voters, as it is a new contribution, it was simply declined by dvdprofiler team.

Quote:
@ kutch:

Here's a guide on how to get it right. It's called "cloning".

Quote:

DISCID: will definitely be different if change of region, may be same within region(s), hence: check!
COVERS: will most often be different if change of region, may be same within a region, hence: check!

Reason: We often see same (exactly!) release in different countries, eg. in Scandinavia. The only difference is that the rules states we will only "extract" Overview from corresponding locality, if present in more languages.

Eg. 7332431014275, 7332431007390, 5706141742773 among others!

When cloning these I will have to change locality, SRP (at least currency), and probably overview.
DISCID might be same in multiple contries and even regions. (Often seen in Music-DVDs!)

Quote:
Quoting tweeter:

Quote:
Quoting Jayce:

Quote:
There was no voters, as it is a new contribution, it was simply declined by dvdprofiler team.

Did the cast from the copied disc contain Uncredited?  That might cause an automatic rejection as they need specific documentation.  If so you might want to remove them.  It wouldn't hurt to review the profile cast/crew against the film credits to make sure they are correct.

If they are good it shouldn't take but a moment for each disc.

You say you don't have a scanner yet supplied cover scans from other contribution...that would be reason enough for the screeners to decline a contribution straight away.
You would be better of varifying all crew / cast, SRP, Studios in your submission and since not having a scanner either find a local e-tailer who has promotional pics on their website (copy those) or use no cover art at all for the submission.

Steve
Edit: Sorry Tweeter meant to quote Jayce not you

Quote:
Quoting Jayce:

Quote:
There was no voters, as it is a new contribution, it was simply declined by dvdprofiler team.

Of course, silly of me for asking! 
But did you include sources for all your information? What did you exactly say in your Contribution Notes? Did you just write something like "from previous EAN :###" and that's it?

Quote:
The source is a scan of the cover.
Isn't that obvious ?

I never mentionned the source for the cover so far.

Quote:
- Corrected Running Time by adding all episodes together. Running Time on case is actually correct...

Disc 1: 176:06
Disc 2: 172:11
Disc 3: 173:40
Disc 4: 169.36
Total:  691:33 = 692

- Removed Scene Access... no menu option for scenes with a feature (episodes) per rules.

- Boxset Content added... Child profiles made and submitted
- Disc Info added
- Cast List from opening/ending credits within episode dividers... Character names from credits except main cast list.. those from booklet provided with set.